Contact us!     1-877-355-8012  /  [email protected]

Vielight Logo
0

Your cart is currently empty.

Vielight Shop
0

Your cart is currently empty.

Vielight Logo
0

Your cart is currently empty.

Irradiance is Power: The Key to Effective Brain Photobiomodulation

In brain photobiomodulation, near-infrared (NIR) light within the 810–1100 nm wavelength range offers beneficial cellular effects and deep tissue penetration. However, if the wavelength is optimal but the irradiance (surface power density) is too weak, penetration will be minimal or nonexistent.

The two most critical factors determining the efficacy of this therapy are irradiance (surface power density) and wavelength, which determine depth and cellular effects. This article explores the significance of these metrics and why brain PBM requires a higher irradiance than natural sunlight to achieve its unique benefits.

Understanding Irradiance in Photobiomodulation

Irradiance, measured in milliwatts per square centimeter (mW/cm²), refers to the concentration and intensity of light energy delivered to a specific area.

  • Irradiance is the concentration of light energy delivered to a specific area, and in brain photobiomodulation, it determines how effectively the light can stimulate brain cells and improve function.
  • Think of irradiance as the brightness of a light source —it needs to be strong enough to reach and activate your brain cells. If it’s too weak, the light won’t penetrate deeply or have any meaningful effect on your cells. Sunlight can be a useful benchmark.

Why Brain PBM Needs a Higher Irradiance than Sunlight

Brain PBM devices should be designed to deliver focused, high-irradiance light directly to the head within the NIR range and bypass hair, to ensure benefits beyond what can be achieved through standard sunlight exposure. The Vielight Neuro, which is supported by the most published brain photobiomodulation studies across a wide variety of fields has an irradiance exceeding 200 mW/cm² to ensure sufficient energy reaches neural tissues.

In published studies, higher irradiance levels enable targeted stimulation of mitochondrial activity, leading to enhanced cognitive function, improved mood, and potential therapeutic effects for conditions like Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s Disease and traumatic brain injury. Higher irradiance levels also enable full transcranial coverage with fewer LEDs.

A 2024 systematic review that screened 2,133 records and included 97 brain-PBM studies reports that irradiance (power density) was typically ~250 mW/cm². This is because getting light energy through the skull, skin and cerebral spinal fluid requires a lot of energy and an appropriate wavelength to trigger beneficial neurophysiological effects.

Why Irradiance is Necessary

For comparison, natural sunlight in the near-infrared (NIR) range is free and typically has an irradiance of 50-100 mW/cm² at the Earth’s surface. While sunlight exposure provides some level of photobiomodulation—notably through NIR light—its diffuse nature and accessibility already makes it a routine part of daily life for most people. To provide a meaningful therapeutic advantage, brain photobiomodulation devices must deliver higher irradiance levels than sunlight, ensuring benefits beyond what can be achieved through standard sunlight exposure.

2024 systematic review that screened 2,133 records and included 97 brain-PBM studies reports that irradiance (power density) was typically ~250 mW/cm². The Vielight Neuro slightly exceeds the irradiance used in these studies, which included lasers. Optimal irradiance ensures that enough light energy reaches the neurons, stimulating mitochondrial activity, increasing ATP production, and supporting neurogenesis and synaptic plasticity.

Irradiance Measurement Case Study

As part of their testing program to standardize irradiance reporting, the PBM Foundation benchmarked the Vielight Neuro 3 against two PBM helmets — the Suyzeko NIR helmet and the Neuronic Neuradiant — in collaboration with two photonics engineering firms. Both MegaLab and Optronic Lab conducted independent tests, yielding strongly similar and replicable results

MegaLab and Optronic Lab, photonics engineering firms, conducted two mutually exclusive tests with strongly similar results:

  1. Read the full independent test report from Optronic Lab here.
  2. Read the full independent test report from MegaLab here.
  3. Megalab’s testing methodology.

Based on the 2024 systematic review of 97 brain-PBM studies, the Vielight Neuro (180-350 mW/cm2) is inline with the 250 mW/cm2 average, which included lasers. The Neuronic and Suzyeko helmets only generated less than 5% of the 250 mW/cm2 average.

Source Independently measured irradiance Manufacturer % of Typical Brain-PBM Irradiance (≈250 mW/cm²)
Vielight Neuro (Vielight) 180-350 mW/cm2 Vielight, Canada 80–160%
Neuradiant 1070 (Neuronic) 9 mW/cm2 Suyzeko, China
(Private-labelled)
≈4%
Suyzeko PBM Helmet (Suyzeko) 5 mW/cm2 Suyzeko, China 3%
Natural Sunlight 100 mW/cm2 Free 40%

Vielight Neuro vs Suyzeko and Neuronic helmets

This is a simple, replicable qualitative test that highlights the differences between Vie-LED technology and a 1070nm helmet (Neuronic Neuradiant), currently available. The aim is to test the importance of form factor, irradiance and wavelength to deliver NIR light energy through a real human skull (large adult male). This footage captures the near-infrared (NIR) energy footprint of the Vielight Neuro Pro 2 and a 1070nm helmet using a real human skull. The human eye cannot see the 810nm and 1070nm wavelengths, which requires a digital camera with little to no IR filtering to perceive the beam’s intensity.

Studies support a higher irradiance

Vielight technology is featured in the most published research in the field of brain photobiomodulation by a significant margin.

Be cautious of companies attributing research conducted with Vielight devices or other devices as attainable to their own.

Brain photobiomodulation is parameter-specific and our Vie-LED technology generates a unique laser-like profile and an industry-leading irradiance, which other devices cannot easily emulate.

The table below is a benchmark studies published comparison against other random PBM helmets.

Technology Form Factor Research Manufacturer Medical Grade
Vielight Neuro (Vielight) Modular 20 published
(17 ongoing)
Vielight, Canada Yes
Weber Medical LED Infrared Helmet Helmet 0 published Suyzeko, China
(Private-labelled)
Neuradiant 1070 (Neuronic) Helmet 2 published Suyzeko, China
(Private-labelled)
Suyzeko PBM Helmet (Suyzeko) Helmet 1 published Suyzeko, China

The Role of Wavelength in PBM

The wavelength of light, measured in nanometers (nm), determines how deeply light penetrates biological tissues. For brain photobiomodulation, wavelengths in the red (600-700 nm) and NIR (800-1100 nm) ranges are most effective. These wavelengths can penetrate the scalp and skull to reach cortical and subcortical brain structures.

The NIR range, particularly around 810 nm, is often favored in brain PBM due to its superior tissue penetration. This wavelength optimally interacts with cytochrome c oxidase, a key enzyme in the mitochondrial respiratory chain, enhancing cellular energy production. This wavelength’s interaction with neurons can induce mitochondrial stimulation, promoting cellular energy production and neuroprotection.

The 1064nm wavelength is a promising candidate for brain photobiomodulation (PBM) due to its ability to penetrate marginally deeper into tissues compared to shorter wavelengths. However, the 1064nm light interacts strongly with water molecules, abundant in biological tissues, leading to loss of energy absorption by the mitochondria, the primary target for PBM therapy.

An irradiance higher than sunlight coupled with a wavelength in the 810nm-1100nm range is ideal for brain photobiomodulation.

Practical Applications and Considerations

For effective brain photobiomodulation, both irradiance and wavelength must be optimized. Devices with adjustable settings allow practitioners to tailor therapy to individual needs, ensuring that the light penetrates deeply enough without causing overheating or discomfort.

Key Recommendations:

  1. Irradiance: Aim for devices with an irradiance of at least 100 mW/cm² for brain PBM, significantly exceeding the levels provided by natural sunlight.
  2. Wavelength: Prioritize NIR wavelengths around 810 nm for optimal tissue penetration and mitochondrial stimulation.
  3. Treatment Protocols: Follow evidence-based protocols regarding session duration and frequency to achieve the desired outcomes safely.

Conclusion

Irradiance and wavelength are pivotal metrics in brain photobiomodulation. While natural sunlight provides some NIR light, its irradiance is insufficient for the targeted therapeutic effects required in PBM. Devices designed to deliver higher irradiance, along with optimal NIR wavelengths, ensure that light penetrates the scalp and skull effectively, reaching the brain tissue to stimulate healing and enhance cognitive function.

For those interested in exploring brain PBM, it is essential to select devices that adhere to these principles. By understanding the science behind irradiance and wavelength, users can make informed decisions to maximize the benefits of this innovative therapy.

This article was written by

Dr. Nazanin Hosseinkhah

Vielight | Biomedical Physicist

Nazanin manages brain imaging research projects with photobiomodulation in collaboration with major research organizations, such as the University of Alberta and Baycrest Hospital.

PhD in Medical Biophysics, University of Toronto
Meet the author
0